c. 2026 Cheryl Keller, Rod Ice
All rights reserved
(4-26)
Mermaid Says:
There is a famous poem written by Dorothy Law Nolte titled “Children Learn What They Live” that I so love. I have come across it several times throughout my life and it rings true to me in so many ways. It drives home the belief that children are a product of their environment; people are a product of their environment; that environment in general, impacts our lives as humans to such an enormous degree that it shapes our very being. It begins with such lines as “If children live with criticism, they learn to condemn. If children live with hostility, they learn to fight.” It continues with similar verses but gradually morphs into more positive correlations showing that contradictorily, if the environment in which children are brought up embraces qualities such as praise, honesty, and kindness that they learn more positive behaviors such as appreciation, truthfulness and respect. Not to mention the one thing that above all else rises to the top - love; love for oneself and love for others.
There is also an opinion among some that a person can just be born bad, or to be more dramatic, evil. As a lover of true crime books, documentaries and the like, I have come across many stories where a criminal’s childhood was shown to be, for lack of a better phrase, perfectly normal. He/she had a loving, solid core family with values, good schooling and support, ample resources where needs and wants were regularly met, leaving people in their fold clueless without something upon which to lay the blame. Of course, a strong majority of criminal back stories are quite the opposite; riddled with abuse, neglect, and broken families that people quickly attribute to the root cause. There are also those who grow up in less fortunate environments, with a lack of positive influences, who go on to do incredible things and are able to elevate themselves into better circumstances. There are always those exceptions to the rules. And so opens the question…how much does the environment in which you grow up play a role into who you become as an adult?
An infant is such a vulnerable being - an empty vessel just waiting to be filled. He/she did not ask to be here and whether or not a couple plans for a child or not is irrelevant. Once that little person arrives, he/she, being so dependent on others and the world around them, absorbs whatever is funneled in their direction; love or hate, compassion or indifference, respectfulness or contempt. Bringing a child into this world is such a massive responsibility that oftentimes is taken too lightly. And unfortunately, as that child grows it becomes more and more difficult to redirect negative behaviors which of course then starts that generational recurrence of certain unfavorable mannerisms. How often you see similar conduct amongst family members - negative, or positive for that matter. Hence familiar sayings “like father, like son”, or “the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree”.
I don’t want to limit my focus on just criminal or negative behavior, and I do acknowledge that mental illness can, of course, be a factor, but there are also other basic personality traits that can be affected by a child’s environment that can present obstacles or on the flip side, help lead to success and fulfillment later in life. For example, something I have seen over my many years in the position that I hold at work is a generational difference in work ethic. There is a temperament at times that I have come across in some of my younger direct reports consisting of a lack of motivation or sense of urgency, as well as a sense of entitlement which leads to difficulty dealing with constructive criticism. This is something I have not come across when managing my more senior employees. It presents a challenge for me when coaching or training and I wonder at times what type of household these youngsters grew up in that led to this behavior, or maybe their individual environment wasn’t the factor, maybe it's more societal, or just inherently who they are…?
Now, what I can speak to is my own childhood environment. It included two hardworking parents; and although we did not have a lot of money, I never felt as though I went without, and I felt most times were filled with lots of love, family and friends, at least in the early years. It was of course a different time then when a lack of technology kept children outside away from the television, playing freeze or TV tag, or red-light green-light in the front yard until the streetlights came on. I do feel that as technology has advanced and cell phones and the internet have invaded our lives, children have had increasing access to information and images that in my opinion, have robbed them of their youth in a way. And, here I go again delving into an area that itself can be its own article. So to redirect, as an adult, I can say that I do feel that I, myself, have a pretty good work ethic. I worked from a young age, always tried to put forth my best effort, and challenged myself to be better, through schooling and the jobs I have held; and last I checked, I haven’t killed anyone or robbed any banks, so that’s a positive! Now, how much of that is credit to my parents or my young life in Chardon, Ohio, and how much of that is just mermaid me? How much did the environment in which you were brought up play a role in making you the person you are today? Or were you just born to be who you are?
Walrus Says:
My friend makes valuable points here, and her referencing of the Dorothy Law Nolte poem is insightful. In a sense, she has answered her own question by addressing the importance of environmental factors, while also providing contrast with differing viewpoints on the subject. Without attempting to ride the fence, intellectually, one might rightly observe that both are important. Family environment and also, personal characteristics and attributes.
Our lead supervisor at my last retail store in Geneva used to observe that he did not judge an individual on what happened to them, but instead, by how they reacted. This basic viewpoint fit neatly with my own experiences as a salaried manager in the business. I noted with much interest that some employees who had come from decidedly difficult backgrounds manifested coping skills that were useful in their work for our companies. While others who had been raised with educational and situational benefits in effect, were lazy and lacked motivation. A line of demarcation could not easily be drawn between the two, because age, social status, and income did not prove to be reliable as evidence for one outcome, or the other.
My friend speaks effectively for a strong work ethic, and I believe that this single quality is worth possessing, more than any other. While corporate philosophies generally teach that anyone can be trained to accomplish tasks, given enough time and a proper setting in which to learn, I often found that it was more like creating a piece of pottery. When at the wheel, one must begin with a workable mound of clay. Our human resource departments sometimes erred by believing that posting a list of names on a schedule sheet was proof that they had fulfilled their duties. But a lack of detail involved with putting ‘the right people in the right roles’ could be counterproductive. At one location, where price changes were done overnight, we were given a young teenager who had literally just joined the crew. He knew absolutely nothing about the operation, or our procedures. And little at all about shoppers and their habits. On another occasion at the same store, a fellow who was legally blind, for driving purposes, found himself hanging these tags. He could barely read labels on the boxes, jars, and cans. So, the results were disastrous.
When I politely observed that these decisions on scheduling were not a result of careful consideration, beforehand, the reaction I received was chilly at best. It took some time to resolve all the customer issues with items marked incorrectly. Though no fault was assessed to those who had been responsible, at the top level.
In both instances, the employees had a reasonable amount of desire to earn their paychecks honestly. But lacked the tools. The former had not been given a reasonable opportunity to grow and develop. The latter had an obvious handicap which should have been noted. He was truly someone ‘born that way.’
Sometimes, however, facing hardships and challenges may hone the abilities of someone to a fine edge, rather than providing a hindrance. One of my most trusted tutors, while I was rising through the ranks from a union clerk to a front-line manager, had served in Vietnam, and been through dozens of local closures, as our company evolved under a variety of owners. Despite the woes of carrying such experiences on his personal resume, he had an undeniable knack for coaching workers, and developing raw talent. When I asked him how it was possible to survive so many harsh episodes, without losing faith, he replied that staying on an even keel was the secret.
“When I got busted down, I would come home and tell my wife, ‘Hey, guess what, I got busted today!’ When I got promoted, I would come home and tell her, ‘Hey, guess what, I got promoted today!’ Nothing had me feeling too high, or low, abut the job. I stayed on course and took care of my family.”
Years ago, I offered advice to one of my nephews who was studying for what would become a career in electrical engineering. I referenced ‘The Comeback’ which was a 1993 NFL playoff game, between the Houston Oilers franchise, and the Buffalo Bills, at their home stadium. Despite being down 35-3, the New York club was able to gather fortitude, go forward in the second half, and win in overtime, 41-38.
“Life is easier if you make good decisions. That does not mean success is impossible in the aftermath, as perseverance may still win the day. But you can save yourself a lot of grief by engaging in a moment of careful consideration, before taking that first step.”
Too often, I had not followed that wise admonition while on my own journey. Yet when viewed with hindsight, it was all part of the learning process. One which my cohort the Mermaid has accomplished, brilliantly.






